REASON TO LOVE RENTER

Real reviews from real people
Compare reviews by city
Easy to read ratings, plus a specific breakdown
Assurance of reliability and quality
Increase information and confidence
Read review comments from renters
Increase information and confidence

Andy's Rent A Car Renter Rated Reviews - Page 14

Total scam. Terrible car condition, which I can tolerate as an island car at a low rate. However, the many insurance "limitations" that were sprung on me at time of rental made the purchased insurance meaningless. These should have been posted on the website, except of course I never would have rented with full information. I expected more from Andy's - a name that I have known in Cayman for many years. Highly disappointing to see such shady business practices.

Report abuse

Mon Jun 15, 2026 - Renter Review

Vehicle was old and very basic with minimal features or comfort.

Report abuse

Mon Jun 15, 2026 - Renter Review

No pressur, but due to my loyalty and frequent bookings, I would wish for a surprise of an upgrade at sometimes on the house, like the other place down the road. :-)

Report abuse

Sun Jun 14, 2026 - Renter Review

We had a flat tire on our vehicle within hours of picking it up. When we called, they came right away and switched our vehicles for us.

Report abuse

Sat Jun 13, 2026 - Renter Review

Great experience, free of hassle

Report abuse

Fri Jun 12, 2026 - Renter Review

I booked an SUV online & expected to get one similar to the picture shown on your website. Instead, I received a Suzuki Ertiga (license plate 173 876). No matter how much you try & tell me that this is an SUV, it is not. It is an MPV (compact multi-purpose vehicle). This particular vehicle needs to be retired as it is well past its prime time. I paid for an SUV & did not receive an SUV. This is deceptive practice. Hopefully you take on board my valid criticism and do better for future customers.

Report abuse

Fri Jun 12, 2026 - Renter Review

Andy’s is the best absolutely zero issue as always.

Report abuse

Fri Jun 12, 2026 - Jen

Quick and easy pickup and return. Would definitely rent from Andy's again.

Report abuse

Thu Jun 11, 2026 - Renter Review

Everything went completely smooth and we were very happy with the rental and the office staff