REASON TO LOVE RENTER

Real reviews from real people
Compare reviews by city
Easy to read ratings, plus a specific breakdown
Assurance of reliability and quality
Increase information and confidence
Read review comments from renters
Increase information and confidence

Andy's Rent A Car Renter Rated Reviews - Page 1

The pick up rep was unfriendly, rude and treated us poorly. It was a terrible experience. He mumbled something under his breath as he walked away from the car. There were some unmarked scratches on the car that we wanted noted. However, on the return to drop off the car, there was a wonderful, smiley, happy and helpful woman. She turned around our thoughts of Andy's. I suggest you speak with the man who check us in about his behavior to travelers.

Report abuse

Mon Nov 17, 2025 - Renter Review

the ease of rental was very helpful! We picked up at 7mile and returned at the airport, both were very smooth processes. Thank you!

Report abuse

Mon Nov 17, 2025 - Renter Review

We’ve rented cars from Andy’s in Grand Cayman for 39 years, twice annually. Great customer support.

Report abuse

Sun Nov 16, 2025 - Renter Review

I felt the quality of the car offered was below my expectations. The seat belt on the passenger side was faulty and although we took it back to Andy's they didn't have the part to fix it. Strangely, we did eventualy have to switch vehicles and both seat belts in the second car did not perform properly. Small things like this because they involve safety issues are very important

Report abuse

Sat Nov 15, 2025 - Renter Review

Easy check in and check out, only a few minutes. No long wait. Car was ready, clean and safe.

Report abuse

Thu Nov 13, 2025 - Renter Review

There was no pick up service but the walk from the terminal was very short

Report abuse

Wed Nov 12, 2025 - Renter Review

I've been renting from Andy's for years and have never had a bad experience. They're the best!

Report abuse

Tue Nov 11, 2025 - Renter Review

We have been renting from Andy's on every visit to the island and that is is over twenty years. Each time we receive the vehicle quoted , or better, without a hassle or bickering, unlike some other agencies I had to deal with in my visits to LA in the states. The staff is always courteous and knowledgeable and will assist in the walk around of the vehicle. Even pointing out vehicle blemishes that I sometimes miss after along day of traveling.