Get Rates

REASON TO LOVE RENTER

Real reviews from real people
Compare reviews by city
Easy to read ratings, plus a specific breakdown
Assurance of reliability and quality
Increase information and confidence
Read review comments from renters
Increase information and confidence

Andy's Rent A Car Renter Rated Reviews - Page 35

Best place on the island to rent a car.

Report abuse

Wed Jan 7, 2026 - Renter Review

Best place in the on the island to rent a car.

Report abuse

Wed Jan 7, 2026 - Renter Review

Best place in the on the island to rent a car.

Report abuse

Wed Jan 7, 2026 - Renter Review

Best place in the on the island to rent a car.

Report abuse

Wed Jan 7, 2026 - Renter Review

I reserved a 7passenger suv 5 mi the before arrival but it was not available when I arrived (it was week between Christmas and New Year’s) at first they offered 2 small cars and then offered an 8 passsenger suv and wanted to exchange when 7 became available, ultimately left me in the 8 passengers no additional charge, which was ultimately a better choice for my large family with small kids. I have rented from Andy’s whenever I need a car in Cayman and will in future and recommend everyone el

Report abuse

Wed Jan 7, 2026 - Renter Review

While I added a second driver and insurance the rates were very good.

Report abuse

Mon Jan 5, 2026 - Renter Review

Very bad vehicles (3rd time renting), bad wipers. Warning lights. Vehicles not in good condition. Cheap=poor quality!

Report abuse

Sun Jan 4, 2026 - Renter Review

Long time renter from this company and satisfied customer.

Report abuse

Sun Jan 4, 2026 - Renter Review

Loved the experience! We just booked late - so it was a bit pricey. Next time - will try to book way in advance. Meghan at the airport office is wonderful! Tell her I say Hi!

Report abuse

Sat Jan 3, 2026 - Renter Review

We chose Andy's rental cars because they were the only agency on the island that had an 8-passenger vehicle available. Everything about check-in, check-out, and the vehicle was great except the touch screen was difficult to operate and/or not functioning properly...but that could have been user error, not sure!

Report abuse

Thu Jan 1, 2026 - Renter Review