Company Logo
Get Rates
REASON TO LOVE RENTER
rr_badge
  • Real reviews from real people
  • Compare reviews by city
  • Easy to read ratings, plus a specific breakdown
  • Assurance of reliability and quality
  • Increase information and confidence
  • Read review comments from renters
  • Increase information and confidence

Andy's Rent A Car Renter Rated Reviews - Page 55

I reserved a 7passenger suv 5 mi the before arrival but it was not available when I arrived (it was week between Christmas and New Year’s) at first they offered 2 small cars and then offered an 8 passsenger suv and wanted to exchange when 7 became available, ultimately left me in the 8 passengers no additional charge, which was ultimately a better choice for my large family with small kids. I have rented from Andy’s whenever I need a car in Cayman and will in future and recommend everyone el
Report abuse
Wed Jan 7, 2026 - Renter Review
While I added a second driver and insurance the rates were very good.
Report abuse
Mon Jan 5, 2026 - Renter Review
Very bad vehicles (3rd time renting), bad wipers. Warning lights. Vehicles not in good condition. Cheap=poor quality!
Report abuse
Sun Jan 4, 2026 - Renter Review
Long time renter from this company and satisfied customer.
Report abuse
Sun Jan 4, 2026 - Renter Review
Loved the experience! We just booked late - so it was a bit pricey. Next time - will try to book way in advance. Meghan at the airport office is wonderful! Tell her I say Hi!
Report abuse
Sat Jan 3, 2026 - Renter Review
We chose Andy's rental cars because they were the only agency on the island that had an 8-passenger vehicle available. Everything about check-in, check-out, and the vehicle was great except the touch screen was difficult to operate and/or not functioning properly...but that could have been user error, not sure!
Report abuse
Thu Jan 1, 2026 - Renter Review
Andy’s is always a good experience to rent from
Report abuse
Thu Jan 1, 2026 - Renter Review
Renting from Andy's was a great experience. The customer service was wonderful. I called prior to the rental to see if I can be picked up and they were courteous and were willing to do that for no additional cost. I ended up not needing the pickup, but the communication was impressive. The car return process was also quick and easy and I liked the courteousness with how they handled everything.
Report abuse
Wed Dec 31, 2025 - Renter Review
I have rented from Andy’s on multiple occasions over the years and never had any issues
Report abuse
Mon Dec 29, 2025 - Renter Review
Had a great experience renting from Andy's during our latest family vacation to the Grand Cayman. They have three locations, including the East End. You can get cheaper rentals, but you'll sacrifice the flexibility/quality. Staff in both locations we've used (the Airport and East End) were very efficient and helpful, we had to change our reservation dates/times a couple of times. The cars were in good working order.
Report abuse
Mon Dec 29, 2025 - Renter Review